St. Thomas Church Rectors
or Clergy-in-Charge
Source: St. Thomas Episcopal Church 1876-1976
| Tenure | The Reverend | Notes |
| 1870-1873 | Charles H. Kellogg | Non resident clergyman |
| 1873 | Thomas R. Street | |
| 1873-1879 | John Newton Rippey | |
| 1879-1882 | Thomas J. Melish | |
| 1882-1885 | James Foster | Non resident clergyman |
| 1885-1886 | Samuel Herbert Boyer | Non resident clergyman |
| 1886-1890 | No Record | |
| 1890-1892 | Harry Von Glenn | Non resident clergyman |
| 1892-1896 | No Record | |
| 1896-1898 | George E. Edgar | |
| 1898-1901 | John Howard Mellish | Non resident clergyman |
| Robert Bonner Bowler Foote | Non resident clergyman | |
| Lawrence McKendree Idleman | Non resident clergyman | |
| Thomas Jenkins | Non resident clergyman. Note 1 | |
| Richard R. Graham | Non resident clergyman | |
| Charles F. Chapman | Non resident clergyman | |
| 1901-1904 | Charles W. Spicer | Non resident clergyman |
| 1904-1907 | John Haight | Non resident clergyman |
| 1907-1910 | Benjamin Meyers | Non resident clergyman |
| 1910-1915 | Francis H. Richey | Non resident clergyman |
| 1915-1917 | Guy Emery Shipler | Non resident clergyman |
| 1917-1921 | George Thomas Lawton | Non resident clergyman |
| 1921-1930 | Maxwell B. Long | Non resident clergyman |
| 1930-1932 | William B. Dern | |
| 1932-1938 | Thomas Mathers | Note 2 |
| 1939-1951 | John R. Yungblut | |
| 1952-1968 | Kenneth E. Clarke | |
| 1968-1993 | Robert D. Gerhard | |
| 1995-2004 | Donald Waring | |
| 2005-2007 | Thomas Wray | |
| 2008-2010 | Robert Reynolds | Interim |
| 2010 - | Darren R. S. Elin |
Note 1: 30 years later became Bishop of Nevada.
Note 2: From Milton Mass; St. Thomas was his first parish after graduating from
Cambridge Theological